"We Track the Financial Collapse For You, so You'll Thrive and Profit, In Spite of It... "

Fortunes will soon be made (and saved). Subscribe for free now. Get our vital, dispatches on gold, silver and sound-money delivered to your email inbox daily.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Safeguard your financial future. Get our crucial, daily updates.

"We Track the Financial Collapse For You,
so You'll Thrive and Profit, In Spite of It... "

Fortunes will soon be made (and saved). Subscribe for free now. Get our vital, dispatches on gold, silver and sound-money delivered to your email inbox daily.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Variable Rate World, Part 3: “This Horror Show Is Just the Beginning”

It’s easy to assert that big banks and other holders of long-term bonds will be crushed by rising interest rates, but it’s tough to calculate just how bad the carnage will be and how quickly it will come. Tough but not impossible. A couple of recent Zero Hedge articles provide some data – and it’s brutal.

First, this from July 8:

Chart Of The Day: Taper Fears Lead To Biggest Monthly Loss In Bank Securities Portfolios Since Lehman

Wondering how the blow out in interest rates is impacting commercial banks, which just happen to have substantial duration exposure in the form of various Treasury and MBS securities, not to mention loans, structured products and of course, trillions in IR swap, derivatives and futures? Wonder no more: the Fed’s weekly H.8 statement, and specifically the “Net unrealized gains (losses) on available-for-sale securities” of commercial banks in the US gives a glimpse into the pounding that banks are currently experiencing. In short: a bloodbath.

After crashing from $15 billion to just $6 billion, the reported balance of net unrealized gains is barely positive for just the first time since April 2011. And to think this number had topped out at over $43 billion in December 2012. But the worst is that monthly drop in “gains” of $24 billion is the biggest by a wide margin since the Lehman collapse.

Note the crash in the long-term chart:

Bank bond losses 2013

The skeptics will say: $6 billion? Big deal. The Fed did almost that much in its POMO last Wednesday. The issue, however, is that the AFS line, which runs through the Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income line as the last thing banks want is for MTM to crush their reported bottom line is merely a proxy for how rising rates impact on a snapshot basis the consolidated bank balance sheet of US banks, which at last check had $7.3 trillion in loans and leases (still below pre-Lehman levels) not to mention countless other undisclosed instruments that represent their “London Whale” equivalent prop positions, funded with customer deposits.

In other words, the shorthand is to look at the massacre that is going on in the AFS line and extrapolate it to all other levered commercial bank (and hedge fund) rate exposure. Expect math PhD-programmed GETCO algos that determine the marginal momentum of the S&P to figure this out some time over the next 2-3 weeks once banks begin reporting results that are not quite in line with expectations.

And on the 11th, highly-respected bank analyst Christopher Whalen added some detail. Here’s an excerpt:

Q2 2013 Financials Earnings: The Cost of Quantitative Easing

So let’s look at some of the top banks – JPMorgan Chase, Bank America, Wells Fargo, and Citigroup  — and make some educated guesses about the degree of gross AFS [securities available for sale] losses, before hedges and other mitigating factors that we may see in Q2 2013 earnings next week.  This horror show is just the beginning of the fun, however, because the non-cash mark-to-market losses in the near term begin to suggest what will happen to these banks as rates rise and many of these positions are dragged underwater vs. funding costs.  Like home owners with mortgages that are worth more than their homes, banks too will have investments in fixed income securities that will be underwater in terms of both price and spreads over funding.

Last quarter, for example, WFC had a total cost of funds of about 3/8ths of a point.  But many of the Treasury and agency securities issued over the past year have even lower yields.  As the hundreds of billions of dollars’ worth of recent vintage securities held in portfolio and AFS buckets by banks and all fixed income investors are refunded at progressively higher rates, many of these positions will be generating cash losses for banks and other leveraged investors.

By pursuing QE too long, the FOMC has engineered a repeat of the periods of market losses and negative accrual that nearly crushed the banking industry in the 1970s and 1980s, only worse.  And the G-4 central banks actually plan to keep short rates low through 2015.

The extraordinary gains taken by banks on older, higher coupon securities in 2012 and before during the period of QE will not be available to support earnings in future thanks to QE.  Or to put it another way, the period of “recovery” for bank earnings is nearing an end.  To paraphrase my pal Joanie McCullough at East Shore Partners, “get used to it.”

For JPM, the cost basis for the AFS portfolio was $360 billion at the end of Q1 2013.  Unrealized gains net of losses were about $10 billion or 3%. If you figure that the Bernanke shock was good for an average loss of about 7% across the portfolio, then JPM is looking at an unrealized loss of about $12 billion going into Q2 earnings.

Keep in mind that half of the JPM AFS book is agency securities which have moved down in price 2x vs. comparable duration Treasury securities, so the gross losses could be higher than our speculation above.  Going back to the issue of duration, the average life of agency paper has been lengthening.  Combine long duration with extremely low coupons and widening spread relationships and these securities become very dangerous during times of market turmoil.

The AFS book for C was about $280 billion at the end of Q1 2013, including about $60 billion in MBS, $90 billion in Treasury and agency securities and $80 billion in foreign government securities.  C reported net gains of about $2.5 billion or less than 1% of the total, so figure that the Bernanke Shock wiped out the gains in the portfolio and pushed it into loss to the tune of about $12-15 billion.  Keep in mind that hedges and derivatives may mitigate some of these losses, but don’t look for gains on AFS positions to bolster C’s earnings due to Q2 2013 losses.

At WFC, the AFS book totaled about $240 billion at the end of Q1 2013, including about $130 billion in MBS.  WFC reported net unrealized gains of about $13 billion or about 5% of the total at the end of Q1 2013.  Figure that the Bernanke Shock wiped out these gains and generated gross unrealized, non-cash losses of a further $10-12 billion because of the large proportion of MBS and agency paper.

At the end of Q1 2013, BAC actually reported a net loss on its AFS book of $9 million.  BAC has been aggressively selling higher coupons to augment earnings.  In the Q1 2013 10-Q, BAC talked about how “a decrease in unrealized gains in accumulated other comprehensive income (OCI) on available-for-sale (AFS) debt securities” had negatively affected earnings.  Look for more of the same in Q2 2013.

At the end of Q1 2013, total AFS securities held by BAC was $350 billion.  The bank reported net unrealized gains of $8.8 billion or about 2.5% of the total AFS book.  As with WFC, more than half of AFS securities at BAC were in MBS.  Since these securities have been moving at a multiple to the moves seen in comparable maturity US Treasuries, it seems safe to assume that the AFS will show a fair value loss in Q2 2013.  Call it a minus $16 billion gross, non-cash loss before any hedges or other offsetting factors.

While the mark-to-market losses at BAC and other banks in Q2 2013 will get a lot of media attention, the real problem lies down the road as rates rise and bank cost of funds normalizes.  Indeed, if we see a rally during Q3 2013, many of the paper losses on AFS positions could be reversed.  But in terms of cash flow, the picture is very different.  As in the 1970s and 1980s, in a couple of years BAC and other banks face the prospect of being in a negative cash flow position with respect to many of the securities issued by the US government and agencies during the period of QE.  Then the next Fed Chairman will need to explain why the benefits of QE were worth the trouble affecting the nation’s banks.  Stay tuned.

Some thoughts
The above is a bit technical, but the gist is pretty simple: The big banks own a ton of securities that will plunge in value if interest rates rise. Accounting rules require the banks to tell us when it happens, which means huge losses, plunging share prices and some outright failures. The latter might threaten the survival of other banks on the hook for various kinds of derivatives, taking us back to 2009, where $10 trillion of taxpayer money is all that’s standing between us and marshal law.

This explains Fed chairman Bernanke’s quick retraction of his “tapering” comments and his renewed promise of low interest rates and debt monetization for as far as the eye can see. He knows now what will happen to bank balance sheets and earnings if rates rise even a little from here. The problem is that low rates created the imbalance in the first place, and the longer they’re in place the bigger the imbalance will become. So as with so many policy decisions that follow a debt binge, the choice is unacceptable pain today or even greater pain tomorrow.

Because “tomorrow” will be experienced by other people, today’s politicians and bureaucrats will always choose pain then over pain now. Ben Bernanke, for instance, is due to shuffle off to high-prestige retirement within the year, leaving his successor to oversee the implosion of the banking system.

17 thoughts on "Variable Rate World, Part 3: “This Horror Show Is Just the Beginning”"

  1. The problem is there is no real economy. According to BLS, out a 143 million total jobs, 45 of those are in government, health care, and education (debt, plunder, disease and indoctrination), 14 million in leisure and Hospitality (hedonism), and 15 million in retail (feudalism). The 16 million professional service jobs are primarily dependent on the above. Manufacturing is only 8% of the total economy.
    This is why the fed can’t stop printing.

    How did we get here? Machine civilization, job offshoring, and corporate consolidation destroyed businesses, jobs and suppressed wages. Socialistic governments came to the rescue blowing wealth/welfare bubbles. Now in the process of imploding the fed is out of breath. The scary part is populations expanded relative to blowing.

  2. The purpose of pumping money into the economy is to provide liquidity and the purpose is not to provide money to support the profitability of businesses. Businesses will have to be self supporting in generating profits to justify their existence. By continually pumping money, more and more businesses will depend on this free money to survive, with derivative financial industries riding on this profitability. This is causing the economy to expand on the continual pumping of money and the later QE is tapered or stopped, the more damage it will cause. The longer Fed continue with QE, the more dependent the economy will become on QE. The economic system had been resilient is because in the past, Fed will only intervene when it is necessary during recession. After one or two years, Fed should have stopped intervening in the market, otherwise the market will become dependent and Fed’s money pumping becomes part of the system. The economy is running on bad foundation right now. The recession in early 2000s had the housing industry replace the tech boom for the economy to grow on ‘firm’ foundation. However, I do not see any industry big enough, that is bigger than the housing industry, to take over for the economy to grow on firm foundation. Pumping more money is very risky.

  3. As the Interest Rate on the US Ten Year Note, ^TNX, rises, and as the 10 30 US Sovereign Debt Yield Curve, $TNX:$TYX, steepens, seen in the Steepner ETF, STPP, steepening, then both the Too Big To Fail Banks, RWW, and the Regional Banks, KRE, will be be integrated into the Government and be known as “Government Banks” or “Gov Banks” for short. The banks will be part and parcel of government; their purpose will not be lending as it has been known, but rather check cashing, monetary control, and provisioning of diktat by statist public private partnerships, where nannycrats exericse oversight of the factors of production, commerce and trade.

    The “extinction event” of debt deflation, that is destruction of credit via competitive currency devaluation, coming at the hands of the bond vigilantes calling the Interest Rate on the US Treasury Note, ^TNX, higher to 2.01% on May 24, 2013, as well as currency traders successfully selling currencies short, produced Peak Credit, AGG, and Peak Money, that is Peak World Major Currencies, DBV, and Peak Emerging Market Currencies, CEW, in May 2013.

    Authoritarianism is marked by policies of diktat and schemes of debt servitude such as, regional framework agreements, bank deposits bailins, new taxes, privatizations, capital controls, and austerity measures.

    In as much as sovereignty begets seigniorage, that is moneyness, this week’s surge of seigniorage marks Liberalism peak sovereignty. The Milton Friedman, Free To Choose, Floating Currency, Banker Regime of democratic nation states has achieved its zenith in terms of political, economic and monetary power.

    It is Jesus Christ, working in the economic and political administrative plan of God, Ephesians 1:10, who has produced Liberalism’s greatest, that is most complete, economic and political experience. Through “extinction protocol”. He has released the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse beginning in May of 2010 with Greek Bailout I. As presented in bible prophecy of Revelation 6:1-8, the Rider on the White Horse, who has a bow without any arrows is transferring the baton of sovereignty, from democratic nation states to regional nannycrats, with a goal of terminating democracythroughout the world, first in Greece, with the provision of Three Greek Bailouts, second, in Cyprus with a Bailin of Cyprus bank depositors, and third in Egypt with a military coup.

    When the Bretton Woods system, synonymous with the Milton Friedman Free To Choose floating currency system, really gives way, America’s Dollar Empire, that is the US Dollar Hegemonic Empire, and its globe-spanning archipelago of mililtary bases, will collapse, and the Ten Toed Kingdom of Regional Governance of Daniel 2:25-45, will emerge, where ten regional zones of increasing iron diktat will emerge out of today’s clay democracy.

    The Ten Toed Kingdom is synomous with its Beast Regime of regional governance and totalitarian collectivism, seen in Revelation 13:1-4, which presents ten zones of regional governance, as ten horns on a beast, that also has seven heads, suggesting totalitarian collectivism, where the seven heads symbolize mankind’s seven institutions: 1) Education, 2) Banking, Finance, Commerce and Trade, 3) Body Politic, 4) Military, 5) Religion, 6) Media, 7) Science and Technology.

  4. What? Everything’s great…we need money ,we print it!, all stocks go up, we sell them and buy a new cars………what could possibly go wrong with that system Mr. Minsky?

  5. As I said before, I was very suspicious of Bernanke’s thinking when he started all of this back in May. The Fed has more economic data and information about the banking system than anyone on the planet. How could he not have known that the banks would be behind the 8-ball if interest rates rose, especially quickly? And how could he have thought that rates wouldn’t rise – or, equivalently, bonds sell off – if he telegraphed a tapering of Fed bond purchases and especially because of expectations of an improving economy? Something doesn’t make sense here.

    Nevertheless, we shall see if in fact the accounting rules that require the banks to report their losses are enforced. I suspect they won’t be, or that “unrealized losses” won’t count, or something like that. In the meantime I’ll be rooting for higher rates still just to make them squirm.

  6. i wish theyd just crash already…food storage about to start going bad here. i hav no job, life going down hill. bring it on im just tired of waiting.

    1. ’bout 40 years ago, there was an “oil crisis” and then came the S&L bank collapse, gold went from 40 to 800 per ounce…etc etc. I left the city, headed for the hills….I’m still here Keisha, happy as can be to have dropped out of the rat race and to have started living in the human race. I started a new career in a new place became part of a great community….don’t waste time fretting and waiting, a little prep is OK( but not tooooo much) sometimes it takes a lifetime for the STHTF, make sure you are living that lifetime productively, happily, constructively, not just holding your breath and waiting for……………………………………………………………………?!?

      1. Bill,

        What is your new career? I’d love to know because I’d love to do as you have done. You’re a smart guy. It turned out that you were a little bit early but there was no down side since you like where you landed. If you don’t mind sharing, what part of the country are you in?

  7. Looks like Larry Summers will get the job handling the implosion. But why wait, send in the FBI, and make a quick call to Bill Black who handled the S&L crisis. This will end free trade which should have ended years ago but the people who were getting rich can buy the Congress. Free Trade has been a bust for out economy and how much longer can a trade deficit last? Until the dollar drops. We’ll forced too have an industrial policy and tariffs will come back.

    1. I’d love to see sheriff Bill Black ride back into town and clean up the mess and throw the scoundrels in the clink….but it is as it has always been, the rich rule, politics are corrupt, law is for sale. Every once in a while the street mob rises and the rich lose their heads or hang from lamp posts, but just before things really get bad. I can live with corruption, but “reign of terror” events are hellish to live through(if you live)

  8. Not too worry, Bernanke knows he can’t raise rates and will continue this insanity until something else forces him to stop.

    It’s pretty simple, the path of least resistance.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Zero Fees Gold IRA

Contact Us

Send Us Your Video Links

Send us a message.
We value your feedback,
questions and advice.



Cut through the clutter and mainstream media noise. Get free, concise dispatches on vital news, videos and opinions. Delivered to Your email inbox daily. You’ll never miss a critical story, guaranteed.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.