"We Track the Financial Collapse For You, so You'll Thrive and Profit, In Spite of It... "

Fortunes will soon be made (and saved). Subscribe for free now. Get our vital, dispatches on gold, silver and sound-money delivered to your email inbox daily.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Safeguard your financial future. Get our crucial, daily updates.

"We Track the Financial Collapse For You,
so You'll Thrive and Profit, In Spite of It... "

Fortunes will soon be made (and saved). Subscribe for free now. Get our vital, dispatches on gold, silver and sound-money delivered to your email inbox daily.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

China’s Fake Numbers And The Risk They Pose For The Rest Of The World

Not so long ago, London Telegraph’s Ambrose Evans-Pritchard was one of the handful of must-read financial journalists. He probably still is, but since he disappeared behind the Telegraph’s pay wall his work is invisible to non-subscribers, only emerging when a free outlet runs one of his stories.

That happened this morning when the Sydney Morning Herald carried his analysis of the financial Ponzi scheme that is China.

After taking on more debt in a single decade than any other country ever — in the process helping to pull the US and Europe out of the Great Recession — China recently shifted into an even higher gear, creating a world record amount of credit in the most recent reporting month.

And – more important for headline writers and money managers – it reported exactly the right amount of GDP growth.

This brings to mind a long-ago interview in which economist Nouriel Roubini asserted that China just makes its numbers up, frequently reporting GDP immediately after the end of the period being measured, something that even the US can’t do.

But it’s one thing to for the rest of us to suspect and/or assert that China is just giving the markets what they want to hear, and another thing to understand the implications and explain them coherently. Evans-Pritchard does this in his latest article.

Maximum vulnerability: China (and the world) are still in big trouble

China’s majestic and elegantly-stable GDP figures are best seen as an instrument of political combat.

Donald Trump says “trade wars are good and easy to win” if your foes depend on your market and you can break them under pressure.

He proclaimed victory when the Shanghai equity index went into a swoon over the winter. This is Trumpian gamesmanship.

It is in China’s urgent interest to puncture such claims as trade talks come to a head. Xi Jinping had to beat expectations with a crowd-pleaser in the first quarter. The number was duly produced: 6.4 per cent. Let us all sing the March of the Volunteers.

“Could it really be true?” asked Caixin magazine. This was a brave question in Uncle Xi’s evermore totalitarian regime.

Of course it is not true. Japan’s manufacturing exports to China fell by 9.4 per cent in March (year on year). Singapore’s shipments dropped by 8.7 per cent to China, 22 per cent to Indonesia, and 27 per cent to Taiwan. Korea’s exports are down 8.2 per cent.

The greater China sphere of east Asia is in the midst of an industrial recession. Nomura’s forward-looking index still points to a deepening downturn. “Those expecting a strong rebound in Asian export growth in coming months could be in for disappointment,” said the bank.

China’s rebound is hard to square with its own internal data. Simon Ward from Janus Henderson said nominal GDP growth – trickier to manipulate – is still falling. It dropped to 7.4 per cent from 8.1 per cent in the last quarter on 2018.

Household demand deposits fell by 1.1 per cent last month. This means that the growth rate of “true” M1 money is still at slump levels. It has ticked up a fraction but this is nothing like previous episodes of Chinese stimulus. It points towards stagnation into late 2019. “Hold the champagne,” he said. A paper last month by Wei Chen and Chang-Tai Tsieh for the Brookings Institution – “A Forensic Examination of China’s National Accounts” – concluded that GDP growth has been overstated by 1.7 per cent a year on average since 2006. They used satellite data to track night lights in manufacturing zones, railway cargo volume, and so forth.

“Local officials are rewarded for meeting growth and investment targets,” they said. “Therefore, it is not surprising that local governments also have an incentive to skew the statistics.”

Liaoning – a Spain-sized province in the north – recently corrected its figures after an anti-corruption crackdown exposed grotesque abuses. Estimated GDP was cut by 22 per cent. You get the picture.

Bear in mind that if China’s economy is a fifth or a quarter smaller than claimed it implies that the total debt ratio is not 300 per cent of GDP (IIF data) but closer to 400 per cent. If China’s growth rate is 1.7 per cent lower – and falling every year – the country is less able to rely on nominal GDP expansion whittling away the liabilities.

Debt dynamics take an ugly turn – just at a time when the working-age population is contracting by two million a year. The International Monetary Fund says China needs (true) growth of 5 per cent to prevent a rising ratio of bad loans in the banking system.

China bulls in the West do not dispute most of this. But they say that what matters is the “direction” of the data, and this is looking better. Stimulus is flowing through. It gained traction in March with an 8.5 per cent bounce in industrial output – though sceptics suspect that VAT changes led to front-loading. Suddenly the words “green shoots” are on everybody’s lips.

The thinking is that China will rescue Europe. Optimists are doubling down on another burst of global growth, clinched by the capitulation of the US Federal Reserve. It will be a repeat of the post-2016 recovery cycle.

Personally, I don’t believe this happy narrative. But what I do respect after observing late-cycle psychology over four decades – and having turned bearish too early during the dotcom boom – is that investors latch onto good news with alacrity during the final phase of a long expansion. A filtering bias creeps in.

So sticking my neck out, let me hazard that heady optimism will lead to a rally on asset markets until the economic damage below the waterline becomes clear.

Let us concede that Beijing has opened its fiscal floodgates to some degree over recent weeks. Broad credit grew by $US430 billion ($601 billion) in March alone. Business tax cuts were another $US300 billion. Bond issuance by local governments was pulled forward for extra impact. But once you strip out the offsets, it is far from clear that the picture for 2019 has changed.

Nor is it clear what can be achieved with more credit. The IMF said in its Fiscal Monitor that the country now needs 4.1 yuan of extra credit to generate one yuan of GDP growth, compared to 3.5 in 2015, and 2.5 in 2009. The “credit intensity ratio” has worsened dramatically.

I stick to my view that the US will slump to stall speed before China recovers. Europe is on the thinnest of ice. It has a broken banking system. It is chronically incapable of generating its own internal growth or taking meaningful measures in self-defence.

Momentum has fizzled out in all three blocs of the international system. We are entering the window of maximum vulnerability.

Lots of good data here – something notably lacking in most reporting on China’s “miracle.”

But the best — and scariest — single stat is the dramatic decline in the marginal productivity of debt. China, like the US, is getting progressively less bang for each newly-borrowed buck. There’s a point at which new borrowing doesn’t just product less wealth but actually destroys it. The US and China are heading that way fast, while Europe might be there already.

As Evans-Pritchard, notes, the result is “maximum vulnerability.”


Emigrate While You Still Can

7 thoughts on "China’s Fake Numbers And The Risk They Pose For The Rest Of The World"

  1. Personally I’m tired of hearing about China, especially since I’ve been reading for decades that it fudges its numbers. It’s a lying, cheating, corrupt and communist country.

    But I don’t particularly trust the IMF either, or even the US in certain ways, so all these numbers could be total bs. Assuming they’re not, however – or at least on average reflect accurate enough ratios – then I don’t understand why Xi J. wants to post a strong GDP number for his trade negotiations. I would think he would want China to appear to be weakening and threatening a global downturn to counter Trump’s threats to decrease their exports to the US (and/or increase US exports to China.) Or is it that Ambrose means literally what he implies – that Xi J. simply wants to appear to be the winner in the trade negotiations by giving in so little to Trump’s demands. Narcissists are like that (e.g., “Rocket Man”). Today’s “elites” are perhaps the stupidest they’ve been in all of history (too many examples to list.) After all, if China is doing so well then it can easily afford, say, a 30% shift in its balance of payments to the US. Something like that is going to happen no matter what either voluntarily without US tariffs, or with them. Frankly, an imposition of tariffs is probably the better choice strategically because it would weaken China – especially if their GDP numbers are inflated – by “having” to place tariffs on US goods (and perhaps lose US business presence as well), and it would create the price inflation in the US that the Fed wants.

    Maybe none of this matters because there’s too much debt anyway, but just in case there’s not I can at least hope that all those who think investing in China and enabling that lying, cheating, corrupt and communist country will get burned big time for believing their propaganda.

    1. I still remember the period of time when I lost my occupation couple of months back from my organization in which I have given a lot of time and effort and hardwork. I was by no means into plans like get rich “overnight” which soon after end up being marketing promotions strategies in which you should firstly get very interested customers and then sell a product to people or any person so that they will be in your network. This web-based job has offered me liberty to work-from-home and now a days I can dedicate precious time with my loved ones and get enough spare time to go out on a family vacations. This work has given me an opportunity to make earnings something like $21,000-$22,000 per month by doing very simple online work. Go and check out one of the most remarkable work opportunity.>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.bigto.in/K5rdC

    2. Just one yr earlier I made a decision to just leave my past job and I am extremely thrilled at present…. I started doing work online, for an organization I noticed online, only a few hours everyday, and I get much more than I actually did on my office job… previous 30 days was $9k… The best thing regarding it is the extra spare time I got for my little ones…and that the single requirement for this task is simple typing as well as access to internet service… I am also able to put in quality time with my loved ones or buddies and take care of my little kids as well as going on holiday break with them very frequently. Don’t avoid this chance and make sure to act fast. Take a look, what it is about… xnarecipe.and-you.de

    3. Online work opportunities are becoming a trend all over the over world nowadays. The latest research demonstrates even more than 71% of people are being part of internet job opportunities at their home with no difficulties. Everyone really want to spend more time with his/her members of the family by going any attractive place in the world. So web based income enables you to do the work at any time you want and enjoy your life. However determing the best path and establishing a right aim is our milestone towards success. Already the majority are earning such a nice pay check of $18000 in one week making use of recommended as well as powerful ways to generating income on line. You can start to get paid from the 1st day when you explore our site. DON’T WAIT >>>>> throatedturtle.betrunken.org

    4. If you really want to gain $6061 month to month as a result of using your trusty on-line connection and personal computer therefore Let me quickly go over my practice. 2 years in the past I was working in private agency without being paid satisfactory wages according my difficult work. Well then my best friend suggested me to try home based internet work you could do from a home office when you use world wide web and computer system and the best thing about it we are able to do the job whenever we wish and gain the payments on /each week basis. It’s nothing like a propaganda which you simply check out all over the internet that guarantees to turn you to be very wealthy in just a few months or so. Now a days after using this opportunity for for all this time Let me claim this is the favorite online job I am able to aquire because of the fact that by laboring on this venture I am able to work when ever I am able to. Every Time I was working through private job I were not capable to spend some time daily with my family members but since two years I have been carrying out this over the net profession and so now I have been taking advantage of the leisure time with my wife and children at home or rather by heading off outside to wherever I enjoy. This job is just as hassle-free as looking through web-sites and implementing copy-paste paste job that anyone can ->->->-> eskinswarm.a-loch.de

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Zero Fees Gold IRA

Contact Us

Send Us Your Video Links

Send us a message.
We value your feedback,
questions and advice.

Cut through the clutter and mainstream media noise. Get free, concise dispatches on vital news, videos and opinions. Delivered to Your email inbox daily. You’ll never miss a critical story, guaranteed.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.