Summary
Large-scale traders, sovereign nations, and major companies are aggressively buying up physical silver, leading to a rapid depletion of retail silver supply, increased volatility, and a surging silver price.
Physical Delivery Dynamics
COMEX physical deliveries hit all-time highs in 2025 with 12,575 silver contracts (63M oz) delivered in December alone, signaling sophisticated traders prioritizing real metal over paper exposure as the system shifts from paper to physical.
Deutsche Bank delivered 3.27M oz of silver to JP Morgan (2.26M oz) and Citi (2.16M oz), the largest US derivative holders, who are internalizing physical exposure to control physical silver supply rather than maintaining paper positions.
Market Manipulation Mechanics
CME Group margin hikes raised requirements by 30% in thin trading, forcing liquidation of leveraged positions and creating a doom loop where selling triggers price drops, benefiting big traders who accumulate physical metal at suppressed prices.
Section 1256 tax code allows futures contracts on registered exchanges to be taxed 60% as long-term capital gains and 40% as short-term with mark-to-market accounting, enabling forced selling and rebalancing without the 30-day wash rule applying to commodities.
Strategic Accumulation Patterns
Chinese traders exploit arbitrage opportunities with up to $8 premium for silver in Shanghai, buying physical silver in the US and selling in China for profit, draining US silver supply while Western banks suppress prices.
Sovereign nations like China accumulate metals under national security justification, strategically draining the system incrementally while limiting exports to avoid blowing up the system all at once, with banks and industrial users joining the accumulation.
Retail Supply Constraints
Pre-1965 silver coins (junk silver) premiums rose as high as $2 in the past week after being available below spot, as refiners face margin calls on short positions used to hedge inventory, causing supply tightening according to 36-year industry veteran Andy Schectman.
100-ounce silver bars are difficult to source and priced higher than usual due to tariff threats on primary refiners like Argo, Heraeus, Valcambi, PAMP, and Metalor, with availability decreasing across all major importers.
Market Structure Shift
JP Morgan and Citi are net long and prioritizing physical over paper, with the largest US derivative holders now positioning to control physical silver rather than maintaining traditional paper derivative exposure.
Retail silver supply tightening, rising premiums, and relentless physical demand from central banks and sovereign nations suggest current volatility marks the beginning, not the end, of the precious metals bull market according to Miles Franklin’s analysis.