The speaker argues the Federal Reserve is the signature example of cronyism — policy benefiting special interests at the expense of the public — and that Wall Street lobbied for it and profited from it rather than being restrained by it. He contends the pre-Fed panic narrative is false on two counts: modern output estimates show the depressions were neither as frequent nor as severe as taught, and the real instability came from government intervention, especially the National Banking System’s branch banking prohibitions and reserve pyramiding. He documents that New York’s share of bankers’ balances fell from 100% to 57.5% between 1886 and 1912, then rose back to 77% by 1928 while the dollar overtook the pound as world reserve currency at 55% of global FX reserves, with the Fed’s 55% money supply increase from 1921 to 1928 producing the boom that became the Great Depression.
Top 5 Key Topics
Rothbard’s first Supreme Court citation: Clarence Thomas approvingly cited The Progressive Era in a concurrence on Monsanto’s regulatory capture of the EPA, quoting Rothbard on the “profitable alliance between corporations and government” where firms seek government cartelization after private cartels fail. The speaker calls the Wall Street–Fed relationship the ultimate case of that alliance.
Wall Street’s two problems before 1913: New York banks were losing bankers’ balances to Chicago and St. Louis after both became central reserve cities in 1887, prompting National City’s Frank Vanderlip to write in 1908 that “something radical” was needed to meet the competition. Separately, the dollar ranked behind the pound, franc, and mark, and Paul Warburg of Kuhn Loeb complained Wall Street paid “annual tribute” to Europe — his objection being not tribute itself but that it flowed the wrong direction.
Jekyll Island and the “patriotic conspiracy” framing: Roughly six men — Warburg, Nelson Aldrich, Henry P. Davison, Vanderlip, A. Piatt Andrew, and circumstantially Benjamin Strong — drafted what became the Federal Reserve Act at JP Morgan’s exclusive Georgia club in late 1910. He mocks Roger Lowenstein’s description of them as “patriotic conspirators,” asking where the non-patriotic conspiracies are, and notes federalreservehistory.org now concedes the meeting laid the foundation.
Capture of the machinery after passage: Warburg went onto the Federal Reserve Board and Strong became governor of the New York Fed, with Warburg writing to Strong that he should “frame the bylaws so as to give yourself sufficient power.” Strong dominated the system until his 1928 death; his old firm Bankers Trust became one of the Fed’s first primary dealers, and Warburg’s own International Acceptance Bank was among the few banks the Fed bought acceptances from.
Who gained and who paid: The 65% money supply increase from 1914 to 1918 flowed to early receivers — JP Morgan and Company’s assets rose 110%, Morgan Jr. was the 13th richest American and George Baker the fourth — while the public absorbed roughly 50% consumer price inflation and falling real incomes. Wall Street also financed its own think tank, the Council on Foreign Relations, whose Foreign Affairs praised Strong’s “vision, wisdom, and energy” in July 1929.