Shapiro argues that the post-Cold War shift from 1990s optimism to today’s fractured “1930s-style” politics was not inevitable but the product of avoidable choices reducible to one word: unilateralism. He makes the case that the West squandered a historic opportunity to fold Russia into NATO and the EU (Yeltsin and early Putin both wanted in) by instead expanding NATO eastward, calling George Kennan’s “fateful misjudgment” verdict spot-on, while neglecting a Marshall Plan for Russia that pushed Yeltsin toward the oligarchs and “gangster capitalism.” He traces a “thin end of the wedge” from the 1999 NATO bombing of Yugoslavia (the first major action without Security Council authorization) through the post-9/11 toppling of the Taliban and the Iraq invasion driven by a neoconservative empire-building agenda, with the Afghanistan and Iraq wars alone costing over $4.3 trillion and the broader war on terror reaching roughly $8 trillion by 2020. He contends the 2008 financial crisis shattered both the international Washington Consensus and domestic elite legitimacy, and that the resulting hypocrisy (bank bailouts and Goldman bonuses amid austerity) bred the cynicism and zero-sum worldview that ultimately produced Trump.
Top 5 Key Topics
Unilateralism as root cause: Shapiro reduces the book’s argument to one word, defining it internationally as the refusal across the Bush, Clinton, and second Bush administrations to radically refashion Cold War structures. He stresses this is not hindsight, since figures from Nixon to George Kennan, Sam Nunn, Mitterrand, and Genscher argued against the path actually taken at the time.
The missed Russia opportunity: He argues NATO should have been disbanded or included Russia from the start, noting Yeltsin was “desperate” to integrate and Putin angled to join NATO and the EU during his first three years. Clinton instead expanded NATO (Poland, Hungary, Czech Republic joining in 1999) partly to court Polish, Hungarian, and Czech voters in swing states like Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania after Gingrich’s 1994 takeover.
Gangster capitalism and neglect: Shapiro contends Clinton, focused on paying down Reagan-era debt, refused to spend political capital on a Russian Marshall Plan and dribbled out aid, driving Yeltsin to the oligarchs via schemes like “loans for shares.” By 2003 Putin had prepaid most debt and built a $160 billion rainy-day fund, insulating Russia by the time it could push back.
9/11, the neocons, and Iraq: He argues toppling the Taliban was a choice, not a necessity, since generals wanted 3,000-5,000 special forces to target al-Qaeda while Mullah Omar had been trying to expel them; instead the US backed the losing Northern Alliance and created a failed state. Fringe neocons like Wolfowitz, Cheney, Rumsfeld, and Pearl (Project for a New American Century signatories) seized control after 9/11, pursuing democracy “at the point of a gun” on the false assumptions it could be cheaply created and would be pro-American.
2008 as dual inflection point: Shapiro frames the crisis as ending the perception that the US ran the global economy, opening space for China’s Belt and Road and the “Beijing consensus,” while Greenspan stood “in stunned disbelief” and elites reached for the Keynesian tools they had denounced. He emphasizes the hypocrisy of bailing out banks and paying Goldman bonuses (averaging around $600,000 per employee) amid austerity as the trust-breaking catalyst that cleaved American society and led toward Trump in 2016.