Home » Economy » They’re Lying To Us, Part 1: Unemployment

They’re Lying To Us, Part 1: Unemployment

by John Rubino on June 16, 2014 · 15 comments

One of the frustrating things about the monthly US jobs report is the way everyone focuses on the wrong number. The headline says “unemployment falls…” which sounds great, while the small print, which almost no one seems to read, explains that most of the improvement is due to people dropping out of the labor force. The number of new jobs created is frequently small or negative.

It’s understandable — though of course not admirable — that the government would try to spin its economic statistics to make itself look good. What is less understandable is why the media, whose job is supposedly to report the truth, are willing to take the lie at face value.

So it’s worth noting when someone breaks from the pack and actually analyzes the data, as the New York Times did today:

Measuring Recovery? Count the Employed, Not the Unemployed

South Carolina’s unemployment rate dropped to 5.3 percent in April, lower than in December 2007, when it stood at 5.5 percent on the eve of the Great Recession.

The share of South Carolina adults with jobs, however, has barely rebounded.

The same contrast is visible in most states. Unemployment rates, the most familiar and famous of labor market indicators, are nearing pre-recession lows. But the shares of adults with jobs — or employment rates — look much less healthy.

The reason is that the numbers are not quite two sides of a coin. The employment rate counts everyone with a job, while the unemployment rate counts only people actively seeking work. It excludes most people who are unemployed.

After most recessions, the numbers have moved in sync as the share of the population neither working nor looking has remained fairly constant. But after this recession, the middle ground has ballooned as fewer people try to find jobs.

As a result, the employment rate has become the more accurate indicator of the nation’s sluggish and perhaps permanently incomplete economic recovery.

It shows that the economy is improving. Employment rates have climbed above the post-recession nadir in every state, although the improvements are often quite small. In Mississippi, the employment rate is just 0.1 percent above its recent low.

It also shows that the recovery has a long way to go. Employment rates have rebounded in some states with strong growth, like Utah, Nebraska and Montana. But only three states — Maine, Texas and Utah — have retraced more than half their losses.

The slow progress hints at a bleak reality. Most economists do not expect employment rates to rebound completely. A growing share of adults is too old to work, because baby boomers are aging into retirement while fewer immigrants are arriving to take their places in the work force. The share of workers claiming disability benefits, or retiring early, also increased sharply in recent years.

Here’s a chart from John Williams at ShadowStats showing how unemployment would look if the government counted the people dropping out of the workforce as unemployed. The blue line includes all drop-outs, and is not only at Depression-era levels but is still rising.

Unempolyment shadowstats 2014

In an honest world, this “bleak reality,” as the New York Times puts it, would be the story. And though the Times omits the obvious discussion of why the government is focusing on the wrong number, the paper still deserves recognition for lifting the curtain a bit.

 

  • Pingback: John Rubino - They’re Lying To Us, Part 1: Unemployment()

  • Bill Johns

    A simple question. Can anyone identify any government statistic which impacts the whole of the nation which you would accept as being accurate to the best degree possible without any spin or manipulation? Just wondering.

    • Perplexed

      Not me. Too much motivation to lie. Especially in this administration. Heck, the entire person is a lie.

    • useyourhead2

      With the “Bunch” we have running the Obama Administration, including our Campaigner/Vacationer-in-Chief who operates by “remote control” and only knows by reading the newspaper what he and his minions are doing, there is absolutely NOTHING that may be taken as truthful on its face.

    • MacFly1

      Yes, it is: 92 million Americans are currently unemployed.

      • Bill Johns

        You didn’t say the source of your number. Is that the official BLS number? Is that counting all the folks of normal working age who gave up looking and dropped off the unemployed count? John Williams of ShadowStats used the counting methods the government used up until recently and claims that using traditional methods for counting the unemployed we should be up around 20+%. (And using the methods used until relatively recently,our inflation is somewhere around 7%, sorry Janet.)

  • B

    It’s sad that the leading newspaper in our county gets congratulated for finally reporting part of the truth.

  • pipefit9

    I think this falls into the category of ‘what else would you expect?’

    Just listen to all the chatter about the Sunni rebels overrunning much of Iraq. There is nary a mention that this is the same group that we’re supporting in Syria. You would think the media would be having a field day with this connection. Instead, they’re hoping the American people will be too stupid to figure it out, or too apathetic to care.

    So you see, we don’t even have a ‘news media’ any more. Just a bunch propaganda outlets. Welcome to 1984.

    • MacFly1

      Yes, the U.S. media is now completely propaganda.

  • Pingback: Tuesday Morning Links | timiacono.com()

  • Pingback: Prepper News Watch for June 17, 2014 | The Preparedness Podcast()

  • Pingback: They’re Lying To Us, Part 1 – Unemployment – John Rubino | Buysilver.sg()

  • http://barefootblogger.siterubix.com/ Gen

    I’ve got a very nice bridge in my backyard I’d like to put up for sale…

  • Pingback: The Decline of WorkBig Online News | Big Online News()

  • kushal kumar

    CONCLUSION :-
    ” Downward trend in world economy
    is likely to be in mild form during

    November, 2014 to
    April, 2015, to grow somewhat intense during May, 2015

    to October,
    2015, becomes harsh during November, 2015 to July, 2016.

    Such areas of life
    as minerals and metals, foodcrops, energy resources , defence and
    security of nations are likely to bear the brunt of these trends.

    Collective wisdom
    in decision making, communication systems, aviation industry, and the
    cinema , music and TV industries are also , in addition, likely to
    be touched by these trends.

    Countries or regions whose names begin with the letters B , E ,
    EU, N, O, P, U or V may need to implement multilevel approach to
    challenges during this period”.

    This is the substance or salient feature of my article – ”
    Stressful times ahead for world economy in 2015 and 2016″ published online on June 2, this year with astrologyweekly.


[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com] [Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com] [Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]